And this is why the whole #bothvotesSNP was flawed from the start…
Lothian region results, SNP comes out on TOP with 118k votes, counting 36,2% of all votes and get zero seats.
SNP: 36.2% – 0 seats
Tories: 22.9% – 3 seats
Labour: 20.8% – 2 seats
Greens: 10.6% – 2 seats
I'm really grateful for the 2 green seats but I'm hoping that the SNP will rethink their strategy for next time and remember that they are not the only pro-independence party in Scotland.
Embedded Link
Lothian – Scottish Parliament electoral region – Election 2016 – BBC News
Get the latest news for Lothian in the 2016 Scottish Parliament election from BBC News
Google+: Reshared 1 times
Google+: View post on Google+
Post imported by Google+Blog. Created By Daniel Treadwell.
You can't really argue against proportional representation though for the regional vote.
It is what it is.
I'm not arguing against the system just against the flawed SNP argument that more votes for the regional constituencies would give them more seats.
Well it would wouldn't it. If 100% voted for SNP and no other party in the regional vote they'd have taken them all.
Voting against them in the regional vote isn't going to give them seats necessarily.
The beauty of PR is you can't game the system.
Meanwhile the constituency vote is still good ol' FPTF which means my MSP is now Ruth "tank rider" Davidson 🙁
but to be honest I've no idea how the PR part is really counted I just assume they do it right.
I don't think % gives a true picture of what went on.
Looking back at 2011 results the SNP didn't have any lothian regional seats then either
This might help you understand the system:
Here's a link to the actual figures for the regional vote.
http://www.edinburgh.gov.uk/downloads/file/7590/lothian_region_full_results_2016
aha, that is much clearer, thanks +Jean-Loup Rebours-Smith
It is a bit of a stretch to imagine that the SNP have any interest in more green MSPs. While the greens might be the only other pro-independence party, it is clear that another vote on independence is not something that will be driven by the makeup of our new parliament; rather, it depends on the public mood changing significantly. In the mean time, the SNP are focusing on the business of government, and if anything, will be concentrating on how they can implement their tax and spending plans. And there isn’t much common ground between the SNP and the greens when it comes to fiscal matters.
And it probably benefits them that the opposition is split between two sizeable parties — Labour and the Tories — rather than having a single dominant opposition.