I am looking at the state of some of Google's recent products and I am wondering. How was all this planned out?
Let's rewind a second: I'm a developer, I may not be the best or the most knowledgeable but I know the process of planning applications and the thinking behind "future-proofing". It's no easy task but when your company not only is at the forefront of technology but more importantly contributes to its design it's easy to feel nonplussed by some decisions that were taken in the past 12 months about the way forward for some products.
Specifically Google+ and Hangouts
As a user / consumer you'd expect the product / app / service you're using to receive upgrades along the way which progressively improve the usefulness of the product. Apps will often get bug fixes but on occasion they'll also have new features added.
How often do you see something redesigned from the bottom up? As a developer I could think of many reasons why you would do that but all of them are stemmed in poor choices for the core application at the launch of the product. Given how highly regarded Google developers are technically, that's something of a difficult concept to grasp for me.
And yet a year ago a choice was made to completely redesign Google+ from scratch. The reason given was to change the product from the glue across all of Google's products and services to "an interest-based network". I'm a Google+ early adopter and I'm not really sure what that means.
Where are we going? What's the end game? The Master Plan? Why is it that all of a sudden connecting interests is more important than connecting people? (this coming from a guy who's quite happy to just be left alone) You look at other social networks and they have very specific purposes and are well aware of it
Facebook connects "friends" and families
Twitter gives you immediate news
LinkedIn connects professionals
Instagram is for all those selfies
Snapchat is… uh… sorry I don't know what this one's for.
Google+ connects … creative people? If that's the plan I would suggest to look at the "people" part too. Creativity often requires collaboration, mentoring, learning, debating and not just on-line, in real life too. Right now it feels like spending a lot of time and effort into doing an exhibition done on the high-tech panels of a bus shelter. You may gets lots of eyeballs but most people aren't that interested.
How do you fix that? Honestly I haven't a clue but perhaps a cleaner presentation model combined with more efficient garbage management (i.e. spam) would be a good start
And then there's Hangouts
I love Hangouts, I use it for my Guitar lessons, to chat with my family and to keep and archive important conversations with people. You can chat to multiple people at once (though I have seldom done this, being an introvert an all) and although it has suffered with performance issues over the years it's a solid application with lots of cool features.
Which makes you wonder why come up with Duo and Allo at all
I downloaded both, Duo I am almost certainly never going to use. Allo is really only fun for wasting time with the assistant. Much of what was implemented in Allo could have been done in Hangouts, similarly with Duo and its "knock Knock" function (who comes up with these names? A 5-year old?) so why wasn't it?
Well both Duo and Allo require your phone number to work. The thinking behind it is that you don't need a Google Account to use those apps. You do need a phone though, neither will work on a tablet … or the web. I'm not entirely sure what they're trying to prove by launching apps which don't need you to have a Google account, despite the fact that the majority of users will have one anyway (unless you're on iOS).
So all I can deduce is that once again Hangouts wasn't designed to have this level of upgrades added to it so they're starting up from scratch.
I'll spare you a talk about Photos and how the current offering seem like a poor reflection on what Picasa and subsequent iterations of Google+ Photos once was.
I'll be honest, I really don't like being critical of what Google does, but lately my mind has boggled a little too much to stay quiet on the subject and so some kind of idea of what the plan is would be great, especially since we've not really had any upper management update on anything for a while, not since the Alphabet split at any rate. G+ user numbers are anyone's guess, Google upper management has all but abandoned the product and I know I'm far from being the only one seriously worried about the lack of direction and focus.
There's supposed to be some big event on the 4th but something tells me it's all gonna be about that rumoured line of Pixel phones and not much else. I certainly don't expect announcements from the Streams, Photos and Sharing team but I would like to be wrong.
Is Google lacking direction?
I am looking at the state of some of Google’s recent products and I am wondering. How was all this planned out?
Let’s rewind a second: I’m a developer, I may not be the best or the most knowledgeable but I know the process of planning applications and the thinking behind “future-proofing”. It’s no easy task but when your company not only is at the forefront of technology but more importantly contributes to its
Google+: View post on Google+
Post imported by Google+Blog. Created By Daniel Treadwell.

#plusfinityandbeyond
Totally feel the same way. Google has the attention span of a fly (I'm not certain that's biologically correct but it sounds good) when it comes to its products. This seems to be getting worse over time, with new endeavours fleeting love affairs cast aside on a whim, and only long standing relationships (Maps) still being cared for.
Google Apps, now G Suite (stupid name) declares Google+ as a core app, and 'a social network built for business' what!? Since when!?
I'm making plans to go, my landlord here is an abusive nut job.
Think about it in terms of search algorithms – because, Google being a "search company", it wouldn't surprise me if they did. 😉
If you want to search a maze for a specific node (the pot of gold :)), you basically have three options:
1. You can dive straight in and always take, say, the leftmost path. If your goal node happens to be located on the path you chose, you will find it quickly – but if it is located elsewhere, you might miss it completey. If you get to the end of your maze, you can backtrack from there – but, worst-case, the maze has no ends and you will be lost forever.
2. You can thoroughly search the nodes adjacent to your location – and after that all their neighbors, and so on. You will get to the location of your pot of gold eventually, but progress will be slow. If you finally reach that location, perhaps someone has already been there and took all the gold.
3. You can combine (1) and (2). Define a maximum number of steps you are willing to take (avoid the "overshooting" issue of 1), and then search depth-first (avoid the "slow progress" issue of 2). If you didn't find your pot of gold, you increase the number of steps and start from scratch.
Although it sounds counter-intuitive, (3) is often the best idea. Perhaps what we see is Iterative Deepening App Development. 🙂
+Andreas Bartels interesting analogy, and Google have said they like experimenting in the open to see what happens, or like you say if they can find their pot of gold.
The only problem with this group activity is that while those leading it soldier on with their search, those of us tagging along on the journey might just die of exhaustion. 🙂
Well, +Nick Moore, in iterative deepening search, most of the "waste" (time and resources spent by duplicate visits to a node) happens early on near the top of the tree (the entrance of the maze), while it is relatively speaking still small. The resources wasted there are more than made up by those gained from finding the pot of gold.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Iterative_deepening_depth-first_search
The analogy gets a little ugly here, none of us wants to be considered "waste" or an expandable resource. It might still be true to an extent.
Also, something else, as other platforms have been brought up in comparison to Google+ in the original post: just because these have found their "pot of gold", it doesn't automatically mean that they will stay successful in their position of the maze forever. For every Facebook there's a MySpace – and perhaps, just perhaps, the current changes to Google+ (no matter what we individually think about them) will mean that it doesn't become the next MySpace soon. 😀
The trouble with experiments is sometimes you get lucky and discover penicillin, sometimes you live a giant crater full of ashes.
I was more under the impression that at its heart Google+ changes were driven by what they think users want based on whatever usage data they have rather than requests from users which is where all this dichotomy comes from.
If you shoot in all directions trying to hit a target you'll inevitably get collateral damage. If you know what the target is, all it takes is a sniper.
Of the flip side you have Bob Ross' "no mistakes, only happy accidents". I wish more people followed that philosophy instead of scrapping things and starting over.
+Andreas Bartels ever the optimist, fingers crossed you're right. 🙂
Corollary: If you don't experiment, you might have no craters – but also no population to enjoy the crater-less landscape, because everyone died from infections already… 😉
Honestly, I don't even want to argue that what Google does or doesn't do often looks crazy from the outside. It really does, I completely agree! 😀
I just really am an optimist, and hope for the best. So far, I have personally not been on the receiving end of any Google sunsetting, all the apps that vanished were those I didn't use anyway, or where there was a good enough replacement. The fact that Google+ is being rewritten instead of just deleted means that there's still some worth to it. 🙂
+Andreas Bartels what I'm really arguing is the apparent lack of vision. Something that has been acknowledged in terms of how badly it's being communicated. Something which isn't unique to G+ but apparently endemic to several of their products.
Allo and Duo seem designed to try to pull users away from iMessage and FaceTime, that's it. Can't beat 'em, copy 'em. It's disappointing behavior that I wouldn't have expected from Google.
– ditdideje
I guess that system needs some work and enhancement.