Which is better? Rule of thirds or Golden Ratio?

Here is an interesting conundrum, I use the rule of thirds to process most of my pictures and generally I'm satisfied with the results. However I have been curious about the golden ratio and how it works in composing a picture.

Personally I can never work out how to make it useful, so I don't use it. Maybe my pictures don't lend themselves to it or maybe there's just something I'm not seeing.

Do any of my fellow photographers have some wisdom to share about this? I'd be interested to read about your experience using it for composition.

Embedded Link

Why The Golden Ratio Is Better Than The Rule Of Thirds
A long time ago I was a young art student, being told about the “Rule Of Thirds.” I was told it’s one of the most important fundamentals of art and photogr

Google+: Reshared 1 times
Google+: View post on Google+

Post imported by Google+Blog. Created By Daniel Treadwell.

5 thoughts on “Which is better? Rule of thirds or Golden Ratio?”

  1. I can't say that I do! I use the rule of thirds (losely at times), and ignore the golden ratio. I ignore it because every time I see somebody talking about it, they always just seem like reading too much into the composition of a photograph, arbitrarily superimposing the curve onto an image that might as well have been rule of thirds.

    When I teach my students (high school English) rhetoric and public speaking, I place emphasis on ethos, pathos, logos, and of course parallelism and groupings of three. Cliché as it may be, I don't think this 2500 year old practice continues because it just doesn't work. It does! And dividing a photo into threes is no different. There is a simple minimal aesthetic about it. Sure, I could make a photo fit into some fibonacci scheme, but yeah, who cares. It reminds me of every digital song I've created. They don't sound like the real thing. What makes them sound real is when a note strikes just a hundredth millisecond off from the exact beat, and just slightly off key. Makes the sound "thicker". Like bacon and chicken creating a wider taste of meat.

    Why not take the golden ratio further. Why does everyone assume it should be applied edge to edge? If that scene (in this post) has some golden ratio to it, why must the actual frame of the camera/image follow this? Why not align the center of that golden spiral right where the rule of thirds line up, edge of the picture be damned?

    And what of square format images?

    I think it's all just over-schooling. There's a point when I've taught my students too much. We have to call it a day. They have to go on to other subjects. If minimalism works IN a photograph, it ought to work when taking one.

  2. +Jacob Dix Thanks, excellent analysis. It very much sounds like you have the same perception of the superimposed golden ratio as I do, which is to say I don't see how it draws the eye.

    The example in the article with the car door was most teling to me as my eye is first and foremost drawn to the people lit in the middle, I was only drawn to the car door because the article mentioned it.

  3. +Jean-Loup Rebours-Smith I was struck by the image of the woman with red dress, guy on the bed. Sure, his leg follows the golden rule, but I didn't follow it around the image to the door, and then to her breast! Haha

    For me, the best composition is the most basic, corner to corner. Whether it's top right to bottom left or top left to bottom right, I'm good. This image has that. Her eyes vs his, back and forth. Her arm, the lamp between them, and his arm around his leg… these cause me to go back and forth between them. Even the shadow of his head, and the lines of the door point in that direction.

    I don't think composition is the full story, but I think combined with other aspects, it's this back and forth of the eye that makes an image appealing. I've written a piece about it here: http://www.mobilography.net/what-makes-a-good-photograph/

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Scroll to Top