Spider-man: Homecoming, quick review

We went to see the new Spider-man on Sunday and I thought I'd lay down some thoughts about the movie. As always be warned that this will contain spoilers so if you haven't seen the movie yet, read on at your own risk.

I want to discuss what I thought worked first but just so you know not everything worked and some parts left me a little irked, but more on that later.

First a little background. I can't say I'm terribly familiar with the entire comics canon of Spider-man. I did see all 5 previous movies and I have watched some of the Ultimate Spider-man cartoon and therefore have a certain amount of expectations when it comes to the character.

I think bringing Peter back to High School with the ups and downs of what that entails was really smart. Tom Holland may be 6 years older than the age he portrays Peter Parker but he is a far more believable kid with a lot of inexperience when it comes to fighting crime and generally dealing with adults. He brings the kind of wit one expects to see with the costume and add to that all the toys that Tony Stark packs in this tech suit he gives him, the childish sense of awe is always fun to see. I was also pleased to see him experiment on his web fluid at school and him being a generally big science nerd.

The setup for the villain works well and the writers managed to make him somewhat relatable as someone who struggles in a society led by the rich and powerful. He brings a ruthlessness which is borne out of a feeling of abandonment from society as well as a love for his family. That said, he has a pretty sweet house for a "little guy"… More importantly, bringing a new villain to the franchise (albeit a classic comics villain) was a smart move.

Not wasting time showing the origin story was also good. We expected that since he already has his powers in Civil War but that means they don't have to do the whole Uncle Ben thing for the 3rd time. Uncle Ben isn't even mentioned by name at any point though we guess he's subtly referred to during a conversation between Peter and Aunt May.

Marissa Tomei also did a good job as Aunt May, a caring but not overwhelmingly motherly presence in Peter's life. She felt more like a big sister than an Aunt. Previous iterations of May seem to have suffered from "widow syndrome" whereby their character is mostly defined by the loss of a loved one. Leaving Ben out allowed for her character to be defined differently even if we didn't see much of her.

But like I hinted at the top, it's not all fun and roses. There are bits which didn't work out.

The worst part was this break in the timeline at the very beginning. And putting it right there at the 5 min mark (or so) didn't quite spoil the whole movie but certainly irked me a little because no matter how you look at it, based on all previously obtained information from other MCU movies, there is no way 8 years have passed between the start of Spider-man homecoming and The Battle of New York. I won't go into the details of why this time jump doesn't work, I can certainly do a separate post about it, but let's just say there was nothing that prevented the time jump to be the required 4 years (2012-2016, as the movie starts shortly after the end of Civil War) instead of 8.

Another offender, and this is something many movies nowadays suffer from, is the fact that the trailers pretty much reveal the entire plot. Compare this to Guardians vol2 where James Gunn was adamant to only show extended footage from the first act so as not to spoil the movie and in a way that doesn't make a narrative and you get a much more enjoyable movie experience where you discover the plot along with everyone else. Here you just knew he had the suit, discovered the vulture's band selling stuff made out of re purposed alien tech, tried to stop them, eventually screwed up at the ferry, got his suit taken back but finished the job with his old suit and earned his medal at the end. In a way, homecoming was one of these movies where I wasn't really worried about spoilers because there didn't seem to be much to spoil.

I'll make a quick comment about the spider sense since it's been talked about in various blogs. If you're not familiar with it, you won't miss it but if you know the most basic thing about Spider-man you would have expected him to suspect something bad as he walked to the house to meet Liz for the dance or have a quicker reaction when the Vulture wings were breaking the pillars (of heck even that big WTF at the very end with Aunt May). None of these would have happened if he had the Spider Sense. I don't know if this is something they'll retcon somehow but it's not normally something Peter gets from tech. In a way it's somehow substituted by "suit lady" later renamed "Karen", which makes for some comedic moments but shouldn't replace what is a fundamental aspect of Spider-man's powers.

Other things didn't quite work out like the Stark plane flying on its own without supervision, without sensor arrays to detect potential interceptors or any basic security tech you'd expect from something coming out of Stark Industries. Oh and while it was fun to see Peter experiment on his own tech during Physics class, the class supervisor being so oblivious especially in a school of (apparently) geniuses seemed odd. I've never been to school in America, obviously but I've had Physics and Chemistry classes and we'd never have been able to get away with messing around with the experiments we were supposed to work on…

So in a nutshell it was a fun entertaining movie but had enough flaws that even the peppering (swidt? ;)) of Easter Eggs didn't quite make up for them. In other words, I wasn't feeling excited when watching this which is rare for a superhero movie. How does it compare to the other 5? Well I didn't really like Whiney McGuire and though I like the Andrew Garfield movies, they weren't without obvious tropes either. Yes it's likely the best of all 6 but there is room still for much improvement.

I'm giving it a 7/10.

Spider-man: Homecoming, quick review

We went to see the new Spider-man on Sunday and I thought I’d lay down some thoughts about the movie. As always be warned that this will contain spoilers so if you haven’t seen the movie yet, read on at your own risk.

I want to discuss what I thought worked first but just so you know not everything worked and some parts left me a little irked, but more on that later.

First a little background. I can’t say

Google+: Reshared 1 times
Google+: View post on Google+

Post imported by Google+Blog. Created By Daniel Treadwell.

14 thoughts on “Spider-man: Homecoming, quick review”

  1. I would give it a 10/10 for the fact that it was better than any other Spider-Man movie, and that it actually meant something in terms of the MCU. The Vulture's background isn't comically accurate, but I am willing to look past that because Spider-Man himself was pretty accurate based on the comics.

  2. Thanx for the review I'm going to be taking my kids to see it this weekend I am a huge Marvel and DC Comics fan and I have loved all of the Spider-Man movies and I was pretty pissed when Andrew Garfield was let go and they had to start everything all over again but I love Spider-Man so much I'm still ready to go see this one your review helps thanks

  3. Gave it an 8 out of 10.
    Given of course you accept the whole history of SM was changed and the cast was a PC rainbow disaster.

    The entire 8 goes to the Tony Stark and MJ parts.

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Scroll to Top